Alberta’s changes to doctors’ billing during pandemic are unethical: experts

Alberta’s changes to doctors’ billing during pandemic are unethical: experts

Alberta’s changes to doctors’ billing during pandemic are unethical: experts

EDMONTON — A University of Calgary professor says it was unethical for the Alberta government to bring in changes during the COVID-19 pandemic to how doctors bill for their services.

Dr. Ian Mitchell, who’s a clinical professor of pediatrics at the Cumming School of Medicine, called it a managerial failure by the government.

“It’s about the complexity of a brand new system,” he said in an interview.

“Managers choose the time carefully to make changes in any workforce and when the workforce is already stressed, the manager’s job … is to try to calm things.”

The government went ahead with changes to a funding framework on March 31, despite pleas from doctors to delay them so physicians could focus on the pandemic.

It led to a lawsuit by the Alberta Medical Association, which argues doctors’ charter rights were violated by not having access to third-party arbitration.

Alberta Health said in a statement that the government is committed to maintaining total payments to physicians at $5.4 billion this year.

“With recent changes to support physicians in the pandemic, we expect to spend even more,” spokesman Steve Buick said in the email.

Mitchell said it’s being portrayed by the government as a money issue, but it’s more complicated than that.

He and his colleague Juliet Guichon, a bioethicist at the Cumming School of Medicine, wrote a column outlining their concerns, which was published Wednesday by the CBC.

It suggested the changes by the government were a “needless burden during a pandemic” and called the move unethical and potentially dangerous.

Mitchell compared it to a supermarket changing every bar code on every food item at a time when cashiers are stressed, concerned about their health and worried about transmitting the novel coronavirus.

“They just would not do this,” he said.

“It’s exactly the same thing. They’ve changed the codes, it’s a new system to learn, and people are actually doing webinars to learn the new system.”

He and Guichon argue that the move is also unethical under the province’s own rules.

A document titled Alberta’s Ethical Framework for Responding to Pandemic Influenza, which was published in January 2016, said “the health system is obliged to respond to the needs of the affected individuals, society and health-care providers who put themselves at risk for the good of others.”

It suggests the system must abide by the principles of working together, flexibility and good decision-making.

Buick said that document has nothing to do with physician payment and “deals with clinical and policy choices around patient care, restrictions on public activity.”

Doctors have said that the changes will force hundreds of clinics across the province, particularly in rural areas, to reduce staff or close their doors.

They received support Wednesday from the National Farmers Union, which noted that physicians working in Sundre and Stettler have given notice that they can no longer afford to provide emergency and obstetrical services at local hospitals.

“This demonstrates the disastrous impact on rural communities that is happening as a result of the UCP government’s attacks on doctors,” Glenn Norman, vice-president of policy, said in a news release.

He noted that Sundre is in the heart of cattle country and also serves forestry and oil-sector workers, while Stettler has a lot of grain farming and oil-service work.

“These occupations are all considered high risk,” said Norman.

The organization reminded the Alberta government that rural communities often face difficulties attracting doctors and the health minister’s assertion that he would simply replace doctors who leave shows a complete disregard for the patient-physician relationship.

Mitchell added that the doctors he’s spoken to find the changes confusing and worry about the effect they will have on health care overall.

“We need to cancel all the changes immediately,” said the University of Calgary professor, suggesting the province go back to the negotiated contract that was in place and restart bargaining talks once the pandemic is over.

“People are already stressed. We don’t need to load them with an additional layer of stress.”

This report by The Canadian Press was first published April 15, 2020

Colette Derworiz, The Canadian Press


Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

File photo
A man walks into a Cargill meat processing factory. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graham Hughes
Alberta meat plant, site of COVID-19 outbreak last year, to get vaccination clinics

Nearly half of the 2,200 workers at the Cargill facility contracted the novel coronavirus and two employees died last April

Grand Chief Wilton Littlechild, left, Grand Chief Arthur Noskey, centre and Chief Aaron Young during a meeting with First Nations Chiefs and Grand Chiefs in Edmonton. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jason Franson
Alberta must retract Forest Act before it becomes law: Treaty 8 grand chief

‘We are asking (the government) to pull this back and consult with us,’ says Arthur Noskey of Treaty 8 First Nations

Alberta’s largest school board says it will not use the United Conservative government’s draft elementary school curriculum pilot this fall. (Ben Hohenstatt/Juneau Empire)
Calgary school board says no to United Conservative draft school curriculum

Other school boards including Edmonton Public, Edmonton Catholic, Elk Island Public, Wild Rose, Medicine Hat Public, Medicine Hat Catholic and Lethbridge Public have also rejected it

Alberta reported its highest number of daily COVID-19 cases since December 16 on Friday. (NIAID-RML via AP)
Alberta reports 1,521 additional COVID-19 cases, 674 new variant cases

Daily case total the highest since mid-December

A cross made out of hockey sticks at a makeshift memorial is silhouetted against the setting sun at the intersection of a fatal bus crash near Tisdale, Sask., on Monday, April, 9, 2018. A virtual tribute is planned to mark the third anniversary of the Humboldt Broncos bus crash. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward
VIDEO: Humboldt Broncos team to be honoured on third anniversary of fatal bus crash

16 people died and 13 were injured when a semi-trailer ran a stop sign into the path of the hockey team’s bus

Chief Public Health Officer Theresa Tam speaks during a technical briefing on the COVID pandemic in Canada, Friday, January 15, 2021 in Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Canada’s ICUs see near-record of COVID-19 patients last week as variant cases double

Last week, Canadian hospitals treated an average of 2,500 patients with COVID-19, daily, up 7% from the previous week

Vancouver’s park board general manager issued a new order Friday restricting tents and other temporary structures from being set up in Strathcona Park after April 30, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jonathan Hayward
Vancouver park board issues order to restrict tents in Strathcona Park

The order issued Friday restricted tents and other temporary structures from being set up after April 30

Stettler’s own Renegade Station is kicking off the spring season with a brand new single - to be released April 9th. (Photo submitted)
A brand new single is on the way from Stettler-based band Renegade Station

Free Free Free hits all streaming platforms on April 9th

Foreign Affairs Minister Marc Garneau waits for a virtual meeting to begin with US Secretary of State Antony Blinken in Ottawa, Friday February 26, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Ottawa mulls exempting more workers from Canada-U.S. border shutdown: Garneau

Canada-U.S. border has been closed to people travelling for vacations and other non-essential visits since March 2020

A worker smooths concrete at a construction site in Toronto on January 16, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Cole Burston
Economy adds 303,000 jobs in March, unemployment rate falls: Statistics Canada

Figure released this morning outpaced the 259,000 gain seen in February

FILE - This file photo dated July 10, 1947 shows the official photograph of Britain’s Princess Elizabeth and her fiance, Lieut. Philip Mountbatten in London. Buckingham Palace says Prince Philip, husband of Queen Elizabeth II, has died aged 99. (AP Photo/File)
Prince Philip, husband of Queen Elizabeth II, dies at 99

Philip spent a month in hospital earlier this year before being released on March 16

Campbell River city council will continue its 2020 policy of waiving late fees and NSFs. (Mirror File photo)
53% of Canadians teetering the brink of insolvency: survey

A majority of Canadians admit they’re just $200 away from not being able to pay their monthly bills

Alberta Premier Jason Kenney listens as the 2021 budget is delivered in Edmonton Alta, on Thursday, Feb. 25, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jason Franson
Kenney faces criticism from doctors, his own caucus, over new COVID-19 health rules

Alberta now has more than 10,000 active cases, about 43 per cent are variants

Most Read