The rule of law should not be taken for granted

“Travel,” said Francis Bacon, “is part of education” for the young and “a part of experience” for those who are older.


“Travel,” said Francis Bacon, “is part of education” for the young and “a part of experience” for those who are older. But an additional benefit of travel is to remind us why certain places function better than others.

During a recent trip to Hong Kong I met with a plethora of civil servants, some politicians and a few business people, all with an obvious interest in the future of their territory. My purpose was to get a sense of how Hong Kong has held up in the face of massive change occurring in China proper.

While Hong Kong has its own partly-appointed/partly-elected legislature and control of its borders, it faces the pressures of population, pollution, and corruption inherent in residing right next door to China.

Some difficulties, such as pollution, are obviously cross-border, and will only be solved once (mainland Chinese) governments and business hew more closely to the polluter-pay principle and as technology and regulation advance. Others, such as corruption, can be guarded against internally in Hong Kong proper by keeping its own institutions strong.

In general, the Hong Kong mandarins and politicians I met were remarkably clear and unapologetic about two things: First, they want Hong Kong to stay capitalist (imagine a bureaucrat in Ottawa stating that as an end goal). Second, they were determined to ensure the territory continues to be governed according to the rule of law.

Their emphasis on the rule of law might well be the result of being next door to China, whose own justice system, bureaucracy, government and private sector are shot through with corruption and crony capitalism (as opposed to the useful, rules-based and merit-based type of capitalism).

China’s problems with corruption and crony capitalism are partly the result of the inadequate attention it pays to the rule of law and to its weakly enforced property rights. In fact, as measured by my colleagues as part of the Fraser Institute’s Economic Freedom of the World Index, China legal system and property rights placed 77th out of 153 jurisdictions. (That compares to Hong Kong in the 24th spot and Canada at 11.)

That dismal standing is backed up by anecdotes: one Hong Kong businessman told me the most important thing China could do in the near-term is to clean up its corrupt judiciary. But let’s put China aside and look at another useful benefit from travel: it reminds us that one’s own country should not be taken for granted.

While in Hong Kong, I kept up with latest news on the Senate scandal, including RCMP allegations that attempts were made to water down Senate reports on misbehaving senators. While pressuring senators to weaken reports does not rise to the level of a criminal offence, it does reveal a culture tempted to bend ‘in-house’ rules to gain partisan advantage and/or to avoid further critical headlines.

Such revelations came out the very week I met with officials from Hong Kong’s Independent Commission Against Corruption, an investigative body set up in the 1970s to combat corruption that was then perceived to be widespread in the police, government and in business.

The contrast is obvious: here was Hong Kong, attempting to inoculate itself from the corrupt governance next door while realizing the temptation to bend the rules is a constant, regardless of where one lives. While the importance of the rule of law is blindingly obvious, it would be a mistake to think ‘obvious’ equals ‘unlikely to happen.’

Think of all the graft uncovered in Quebec’s construction and municipal governments in the past year.

One critical difference between a well-functioning city-state on the periphery of east Asia or a country like Canada and China is the degree to which rules are predictable and enforced. Those tempted to bend or break the rules should remember such distinctions, as should the rest of us.

Mark Milke is a senior fellow with the Fraser Institute. His columns are distributed through Troy Media.


Just Posted

Generals run away in third to win 5-2 over Ft. Sask

Lacombe looking for the four-game sweep in Ft. Sask on Sunday

Community invited to check out local Toastmasters’ group

New members are sought for the Club to continue past March

Lacombe-Ponoka MLA Ron Orr talks tourism opportunities at Chamber lunch

Stakeholders must take advantage of the Lacombe region’s many selling points

Alberta judge cleared in case where sex assault victim was shackled, jailed

Judicial council: Judge Raymond Bodnarek acted on Crown’s advice, tried to minimize victim’s hardship

Breton/Thorsby RCMP investigate theft of boat

RCMP say stolen jet boat and trailer valued at approximately $80,000

WATCH: Red Deer celebrates one year out from 2019 Canada Games

Community gathers at Great Chief Park to commemorate Games milestone

How to keep local news visible in your Facebook feed

Facebook has changed the news feed to emphasize personal connections. You might see less news.

OLYMPICS 101: Oldest and youngest Canadians to reach the podium

This year, Canada sent its most athletes in Winter Games history, here’s a look at record breakers

Federal budget to unveil incentive for 5-week second parent leave: official

Goal behind the measure is to give parents more incentive to share child-rearing responsibilities

Three-car pile-up on Northstar Drive and 58th Street

No injuries reported at Thursday afternoon incident

Notley says Alberta watching B.C. court bid closely, will get no free ride on it

Alberta Premier Rachel Notley ended the three-week ban on B.C. wine, calming the trade war

Trudeau ends troubled India trip in his comfort zone of hockey and youth

The players, 18-25, came to New Delhi from Ladakhi in northern India, as part of outreach program

Team Canada’s Dave Duncan apologizes after drunken joyride in Pyeongchang

Duncan, his wife Maja and Canadian technical coach William Raine detained by South Korean police

Sask. school shooter to be sentenced as adult

The man was just shy of his 18th birthday when he killed four people and injured seven others

Most Read