VAUGHAN: Tax rate decreases are great until they’re not

Albertan municipalities like Lacombe could face tough realities with further provincial cuts

Setting a tax rate is a no-win for municipalities, especially when they constantly rely on unsteady funding from the provincial government.

Recently, the City of Lacombe attempted to show some restraint by acknowledging the pressures on ratepayers by setting the 2020 tax increase to 0.9 per cent, below the CPI level of 1.4 per cent, which they have set as their benchmark goal.

The loss results in a relatively minor shortfall of $20,000 for the city — which will be made up in a variety of ways none of which will be overly will be a serious threat to major public services provided by the city.

The problem, as identified by Councillor Jonathan Jacobson, is what the City will do if the Alberta Government continues make cuts and alterations to municipal funding.

Funding from the Municipal Sustainability Initiative (MSI) is the key tool used by the Government of Alberta to fund municipalities. With the energy sector continuing to struggle in the province and whispers of another recession surrounding the country— the fear of further cuts to MSI should worry residents of Lacombe and indeed, residents of all Albertan municipalities.

Jacobson outlined his concern with tax rate cuts during hard times by showing how it could affect future budgets.

“If provincial funding dries up, we will have to make a decision between substantial tax increases or significant service cuts. If you go the increase route, to go from 1.4 per cent to say 2.8 or 2.9 is a little bit more reasonable than 0 per cent to 4 per cent,” he said.

In essence, having a steady funding model that can swallow provincial cuts over time is easier on the taxpayer, and city administration who make municipal budgets, than making short-term cuts now that will result in large, burdensome increases later.

Here’s the thing, municipalities are required by law to have balanced budgets. This means municipalities cannot run deficits when times are tough. If MSI dries up, the essential services provided by the City of Lacombe residents of Lacombe rely on would need to continue to be funded by City without deficit spending — meaning the City would have to raise taxes or make cuts to less essential services.

From the way things look, it is certainly in the realm of possibility that municipalities like Lacombe could see provincial funding diminish — meaning prudent and responsible fiscal management is required now.

While 0.9 per cent is obviously better than 1.4 per cent in terms of the ratepayer right now — the difference is minuscule enough that Lacombe residents should consider the alternative.

Politicians will be praised for the lesser tax rate now, but they will be skewered if a significant municipal tax rate is required down the line as a result of provincial cuts.



todd.vaughan@lacombeexpress.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Youngest Lacombe Ram looking to build on solid rookie year

Stretch-4 Aidan Anderson looking to expand his role in the Ram offence next season

Community Initiatives Program (CIP): approved grant for Lacombe FCSS

The total grant amount is $75,000 with projects being implemented from Aug. 1st, 2020 to July 31st, 2022

Water quality advisory issued for Gull Lake at Aspen Beach

Elevated levels of fecal bacteria were detected via testing of Gull Lake water, at this beach location

Water quality advisory prompted by high levels of fecal bacteria in Gull Lake

AHS issued the advisory, and say it will be in effect until further notice

QUIZ: A summer’s day on the water

How much do you know about boats and other watercraft?

Wild blank Canucks 3-0 to take early series lead, Stalock earns shutout

‘Our guys did an unbelievable job staying with them’

With loan money gone, restaurants are at mercy of virus

“At this moment, I don’t see getting my full payroll back”

COVID-19 blamed as work on military port first promised in 2007 sees new delay

Stephen Harper first announced plans to build the Nanisivik deep-water port in Nunavut

Canada extends peacekeeping mission despite Security Council loss

Deployment of a CC-130 Hercules in support of UN missions in Africa

Quebec seeing spike in drownings compared to rest of Canada: Lifesaving Society

As of July 31, the province has already reported at least 60 drownings for the year

N.L.’s next premier will be announced today as Liberals elect new party leader

The party is hosting a leadership convention in St. John’s

A weakened Tropical Storm Isaias lashes virus-hit Florida

‘Don’t be fooled by the downgrade’

Wilford Brimley, ‘Cocoon’ and ‘Natural’ actor, dies at 85

He was on dialysis and had several medical ailments

Most Read